The Pony Grill & Bar Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to The Pony Grill & Bar, a gem nestled in Sheridan, Wyoming, where good food meets a warm, inviting atmosphere. The menu is a tantalizing blend of crowd favorites and unique offerings, each expertly crafted to delight the palate.
- Pork Carnitas Tacos: These flour tortilla tacos brim with tender pork carnitas, complemented by pico de gallo and queso fresca, creating a flavor explosion for just $10.49.
- Steak Sandwich: Enjoy an 8oz USDA choice ribeye on a hoagie bun for $14.49, a hearty delight perfect for any meat lover.
- Chicken, Bacon, Mac & Queso: Dive into this creamy pasta dish for $12.99, showcasing a delightful combination of flavors.
With rave reviews about the exceptional service and welcoming patio, The Pony Grill & Bar is not only pet-friendly but also a culinary haven worth exploring. Don’t miss the hot wings or the ultimate nachos, both perfect for sharing. Come for the food, stay for the atmosphere!
Great Beginnings
Pony Chip Platter
Tortilla chips served with queso, fresh guacamole, and salsa
Raw Veggies & Dip
Ultimate Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with a mixture of cheeses, green chilies, green onions, tomatoes, black olives & your choice of seasoned chicken or ground beef
Spicy Green Beans
Spicy breaded green beans deep fried and served with ranch dressing
Fried Pickle Spears
Breaded pickle spears deep fried and served with ranch dressing or peanut butter
Mac & Cheese Bites
Tender elbow macaroni and a blend of smoked gouda, white cheddar, parmesan, romano, and fontina cheeses lightly battered and fried
Appetizer Sampler
Combination of hot wings, fried pickles, mozzarella sticks, spicy green beans
Bomber Mountain Wings
Crispy wings tossed in sweet and spicy bomber mountain amber sauce, served with celery & carrots, and your choice of dipping sauce.
Hot Wings
Hot wings "buffalo style" hot wings served with celery & carrots, and your choice of homemade bleu cheese or ranch dressing
Naked Wings
Crispy wings dusted with seasoning salt served with carrots & celery, and your choice of two dips: bleu cheese, ranch, sweet chili, red hot, bbq, honey mustard, or bomber mountain
Taco Salad
Your choice of seasoned chicken or ground beef, cheddar & monterey jack cheeses, diced tomatoes, black olives, and green oons served over shredded lettuce and tortilla. Served with mexi- ranch
Fresca Steak Salad
Fire braised flank steak, avocado, queso fresco, pico de gallo, and pickled red onion
Buffalo Chicken Salad
"Buffalo style breast, bleu cherumbles, diced tomatoes, purple onion, carrots & celery
Cobb Salad
Bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, diced tomatoes, avocado, and hard boiled eggs
Southwest Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken breast, black bean & corn salsa, santa fe cheese mix, diced tomatoes, and avocado
Chicken Strip Salad
Sliced breaded chicken strips, cheddar & monterey jack cheeses, diced tomatoes, and hard-boiled egg
Sirloin Salad
Marinated chunks of grilled sirloin steak and mushrooms, artichoke hearts, bleu cheese crumbles, and tomatoes
Mediterranean Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast, fire roasted tomatoes & artichoke hearts, parmesan cheese, and croutons try it caesar style"!!!
From The Garden
Combinations
Homemade Soup Combo
Bowl of soup served with a tossed salad or half sandwich. Sandwich is a choice of turkey, ham, roast beef or pastrami topped with melted swiss cheese, served on choice of hoagie bun
Half Sandwich & Salad Combo
Tossed salad served with half a sandwich. Sandwich is a choice of turkey, ham, roast beef or pastrami topped with melted swiss cheese, served on choice of hoagie bun
Triple Combo
Cup of homemade soup, a tossed salad, and a half a sandwich. Sandwich is a choice of turkey, ham, roast beef or pastrami topped with melted swiss cheese, served on choice of hoagie bun
Steak Sandwich
8oz. hand cut usda choice ribeye served on a hoagie bun with your choice of side
Pork Carnitas Tacos
3 flour tortilla tacos filled with tender pork carnitas, pico de gallo, queso fresca, & cilantro. Served with tortilla chips and salsa
Chicken, Bacon, Mac & Queso
Cavatappi pasta and queso tossed with seasoned grilled chicken and bacon crumbles